What argument does She use to counter his advice about smoking?

What argument does She use to counter his advice about smoking?

• A. She suggests he should focus on fitness
• B. She tells him to quit drinking
• C. She advocates for moderation in smoking
• D. She agrees that smoking is harmful

Answer: (B)

The argument that supports this response revolves around the idea of promoting a holistic approach to health and well-being. By suggesting that he should quit drinking as a counterpoint to his advice about smoking, she highlights an inconsistency in his behavior. This approach points out that while he may be advising her to quit smoking due to its harmful effects, he himself engages in another unhealthy habit—drinking. This creates a dynamic in their conversation where she challenges his credibility and emphasizes the importance of addressing all unhealthy behaviors rather than focusing on just one. The effectiveness of this strategy lies in its ability to redirect the conversation towards a broader discussion about overall health, thereby making her point more compelling. Instead of merely accepting his advice, she confronts it by bringing attention to another significant lifestyle choice that can also undermine health, ultimately questioning the validity of his advice in the context of his own habits.

The argument that supports this response revolves around the idea of promoting a holistic approach to health and well-being. By suggesting that he should quit drinking as a counterpoint to his advice about smoking, she highlights an inconsistency in his behavior. This approach points out that while he may be advising her to quit smoking due to its harmful effects, he himself engages in another unhealthy habit—drinking. This creates a dynamic in their conversation where she challenges his credibility and emphasizes the importance of addressing all unhealthy behaviors rather than focusing on just one.

The effectiveness of this strategy lies in its ability to redirect the conversation towards a broader discussion about overall health, thereby making her point more compelling. Instead of merely accepting his advice, she confronts it by bringing attention to another significant lifestyle choice that can also undermine health, ultimately questioning the validity of his advice in the context of his own habits.