Which argument type is illustrated by Rick dismissing the athletic program by claiming other sports aren't "real sports"?

Which argument type is illustrated by Rick dismissing the athletic program by claiming other sports aren't "real sports"?

• A. Victory by Definition
• B. Ad Hominem
• C. Begging the Question
• D. Inconsequent Argument

Answer: (A)

The argument illustrated by Rick dismissing the athletic program by claiming other sports aren't "real sports" is a clear example of "Victory by Definition." This type of argument occurs when someone tries to win a debate or discussion by establishing narrow definitions that favor their position while disparaging alternative viewpoints or categories. By labeling other sports as not being "real sports," Rick is redefining what qualifies as a sport to exclude those that do not align with his preferences or beliefs. This tactic can be persuasive, yet it often overlooks the broader definitions and diverse interpretations of what constitutes a sport, thereby invalidating legitimate arguments from those who may support other athletic programs.

The argument illustrated by Rick dismissing the athletic program by claiming other sports aren't "real sports" is a clear example of "Victory by Definition." This type of argument occurs when someone tries to win a debate or discussion by establishing narrow definitions that favor their position while disparaging alternative viewpoints or categories. By labeling other sports as not being "real sports," Rick is redefining what qualifies as a sport to exclude those that do not align with his preferences or beliefs. This tactic can be persuasive, yet it often overlooks the broader definitions and diverse interpretations of what constitutes a sport, thereby invalidating legitimate arguments from those who may support other athletic programs.